All Muppet Movies Ranked: Worst to Best Muppets

Movie Bunker Score:

The Muppets: Ranking the Eight Feature Films from Worst to Best


In celebration of the release of Muppets Haunted Mansion on Disney+, we embark upon a delightful journey through the vast array of Muppet feature films. With their lovable chaos and enduring charm, the Muppets have captured the hearts of audiences for decades. Over the years, the Muppet franchise has undergone multiple transitions, resulting in three distinct Muppet Epochs. In this article, we proudly present a ranking of these eight Muppet movies, from the least compelling to the absolute best.

8. Muppets Most Wanted (2014)

Under the direction of James Bobin and with a talented ensemble cast, Muppets Most Wanted attempts to follow the success of its predecessor, The Muppets (2011). While it doesn’t quite live up to the high standards set by its predecessor, the film still manages to deliver some memorable moments. With the absence of Jason Segel on the writing team and in the cast, the movie lacks a certain spark. However, the trio of Ricky Gervais, Tina Fey, and Ty Burrell injects fresh energy into the Muppet universe with their comedic talents. Playing opposite the Muppets requires actors who can strike the right balance, and these three deliver performances that blend perfectly with the Muppet mayhem.

7. The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)

Although The Muppet Christmas Carol is a solid adaptation of Charles Dickens’ classic tale, it falls lower on the list due to its constrained self-referentiality. While it embraces the festive spirit and features the talented Michael Caine as Ebenezer Scrooge, the film’s adherence to the source material limits the Muppets’ trademark humor and anarchic spirit. Despite this, the performance of Statler and Waldorf as Jacob and Robert Marley adds a delightful touch to the overall experience.

6. Muppet Treasure Island (1996)

Muppet Treasure Island sails into the sixth spot, delivering a fun-filled adventure with its unique take on Robert Louis Stevenson’s famous tale. Tim Curry’s portrayal of Long John Silver steals the show, while the Muppets themselves take a slightly diminished role compared to the First Epoch of Muppet films. The film showcases the challenges of integrating human characters and Muppets in an adaptation. While it may not reach the heights of the Muppet frenzy of the past, it still manages to provide an enjoyable experience, especially with the inclusion of the ever-reliable Sam Eagle.

5. Muppets from Space (1999)

Muppets from Space takes us on a cosmic journey with Gonzo, exploring the existential questions surrounding his origins. The film does an excellent job of blending Gonzo’s personal quest with a delightful array of comedic moments. Notably, the inclusion of Joshua Jackson and Katie Holmes from Dawson’s Creek adds an unexpected twist. While the departure of Frank Oz marked the end of the Second Muppet Epoch, this film rejuvenates the Muppet Cinematic Universe with its fresh ideas and surprising twists.

4. The Muppets (2011)

Jason Segel’s passion for the Muppets shines through in The Muppets, reinvigorating the franchise and introducing it to a new generation of fans. This film epitomizes the spirit of the Muppets, combining meta humor, self-referentiality, and fantastic musical numbers. Chris Cooper’s villainous role and the delightful chemistry between the Muppets and the human cast members make this film a true gem. With its infectious energy, The Muppets successfully honors the legacy of the Muppets while propelling them into the Third Epoch.

3. The Muppets Take Manhattan (1984)

The Muppets Take Manhattan marks the end of the First Epoch, symbolizing a significant turning point in the Muppet franchise. This film captures the essence of the Muppets’ early years with their trademark anarchy and charm. Elliott Gould’s cameo adds an extra layer of joy to the experience, although it may sidetrack us from the core story. It’s worth noting that Jim Henson’s passing shortly after the film’s release marked the end of an era, leaving fans with heartfelt memories and a profound appreciation for the Muppets’ brilliance. Frank Oz’s remark about Disney’s handling of the Muppets highlights the challenges faced by this iconic franchise.

2. The Muppet Movie (1979)

In the Muppet universe, The Muppet Movie served as a groundbreaking road trip extravaganza that left an indelible mark on audiences. It introduced chaos, tears, and laughter, showcasing the anarchy that made the Muppets so beloved. This film perfectly encapsulates the spirit of the Muppets with its memorable music, hilarious gags, and star-studded cameos. The late Peter Falk’s appearance remains unparalleled, and the iconic line from Statler and Waldorf solidifies their place in Muppet history. The Muppet Movie’s timeless appeal ensures that it remains a must-watch for Muppet enthusiasts of all ages.

1. The Great Muppet Caper (1981)

The apex of Muppet filmmaking resides in The Great Muppet Caper, a spectacular show that defies the boundaries of a conventional children’s movie. With its razor-sharp wit and disregard for traditional genres, this film stands apart from the rest. The inclusion of Peter Falk in an unforgettable cameo further elevates the Muppet magic. Charles Grodin’s stellar performance, seamlessly blending with the Muppets, sets an extraordinary precedent. The Great Muppet Caper demonstrates the true essence of the First Epoch, filled with anarchic brilliance and uninhibited humor. Its undeniable charm solidifies its status as the pinnacle of Muppet cinematic accomplishments.


Whether immersed in chaotic hilarity or treading a more restrained path, the Muppets continue to captivate audiences. Each Muppet film contributes to the rich tapestry of Muppet history, offering something unique and memorable. Our journey through the Muppet movies highlights the evolution of the franchise while paying homage to its glorious past. As we celebrate the release of Muppets Haunted Mansion, we eagerly anticipate the Muppet’s future exploits, hoping to witness the return of their anarchic spirit.


1. Are there any plans for future Muppet movies?
2. Which Muppet film has the most memorable musical numbers?
3. Who is the most iconic Muppet character?
4. How have the Muppets evolved over time?
5. How did the Muppets transition from the First to the Second Epoch?