Logan (2017) Film Review: The Emotional Journey of Wolverine

Movie Bunker Score:

The Tragic Beauty of James Mangold’s Logan

A Unique and Mature Superhero Film

James Mangold’s Logan stands as a remarkable achievement in portraying the story of one of cinema’s most iconic characters — Wolverine. Departing from typical superhero fare, this film delves into the depths of tragedy and maturity, offering a unique and emotionally powerful narrative. Drawing inspiration from Mark Millar’s renowned comic “Old Man Logan,” Logan presents an alternate universe where an aged Logan, played brilliantly by Hugh Jackman, finds himself a shadow of his former self. Released in 2017, this film marks the culmination of the Wolverine trilogy, providing an unforgettable conclusion that pushes the boundaries of the superhero genre.

A Dark Western Twist

Unlike a faithful adaptation of “Old Man Logan,” Logan chooses to infuse the Western genre into its narrative, separating itself from its contemporaries. Maintaining the darker and more mature tone of its source material, the film takes viewers on a visceral journey, depicting graver and bloodier scenes than previous entries in the franchise. The violence, though initially startling due to its departure from the clean and polished fights usually associated with superhero films, proves to be purposeful and effectively heightens the chilling ambiance. From the very first fight, viewers are confronted with the shocking reality that Logan is far from a typical superhero film.

A Painfully Depressing Story

Directed by James Mangold, Logan introduces us to an aged Logan, now working as a taxi driver while caring for his ailing mentor, Charles Xavier, portrayed by Patrick Stewart. Reluctantly drawn back into the world of superheroes, Logan is tasked with escorting a mysterious young mutant named Laura, excellently played by Dafne Keen, across the country. The story is a heartbreaking exploration of characters at their lowest points. Charles Xavier, once a brilliant leader, now suffers from a debilitating brain disease, rendering his telepathic abilities unstable and hazardous. Logan himself, tormented by chronic pain resulting from his weakened healing factor, has lost his former heroic persona. The tale is as tragic as it is compelling, and every aspect of Logan combines seamlessly to tell it in all its beauty.

The Incredible Performance of Hugh Jackman

In his seventeen-year portrayal of Wolverine, Hugh Jackman delivers a performance that deserved genuine Oscar consideration. This film serves as his farewell to a character deeply engraved in popular culture. Jackman skillfully portrays a Logan who appears to have given up on life yet remains driven by his desire to protect his loved ones. Shedding the more pulpy, action-hero traits of his previous performances, Jackman transforms Wolverine into an aged badass, commanding the audience’s attention and allowing the film’s emotional beats to reverberate powerfully.

Supporting Performances that Shine

In addition to Jackman’s exceptional work, Patrick Stewart and Dafne Keen contribute captivating performances that add depth and authenticity to the film. Stewart brings warmth and humanity to Logan’s bleak journey, counterbalancing the colder moments with his unwavering charm. Keen, on the other hand, delivers a breakthrough performance, skillfully embodying a character who cannot speak for a significant portion of the film. Despite this challenge, Keen captivates audiences through her emotive expressions and physicality. Her range extends from tear-jerking dramatic scenes to brilliant moments of physical comedy. Keen’s talents establish her as a rising star in the industry, leaving audiences eagerly anticipating her future endeavors.

Weaker Antagonists and Underwhelming Action

While Logan excels in its portrayal of the main characters and their relationships, the film stumbles when it comes to its antagonists. Boyd Holbrook injects charisma into his role as Pierce, a calculating character, but unfortunately, the villains consistently remain the least compelling aspect of the story. Consequently, the climax of the film falls short whenever it moves away from exploring the complex relationships between Logan and Laura. Though the film boasts a handful of creative and exhilarating action scenes, others fail to leave a lasting impact. Despite these shortcomings, Logan’s exceptional screenplay, which received an Oscar nomination, solidifies its place among the best superhero movies ever made.

The Tragic Beauty of Logan’s Legacy

A Heartbreaking Yet Profound Conclusion

Logan successfully captures the essence of Mark Millar’s original comics while refining and elevating the story. The result is a heart-wrenching and mature portrayal of Wolverine that stands as a testament to the character’s iconic legacy. As Hugh Jackman bids farewell to Logan, the film offers a narrative masterpiece that may be unequaled in the superhero genre. While flaws are present, Logan’s screenplay shines as a testament to the craft of storytelling. Its tragic yet beautiful conclusion remains unparalleled, leaving audiences gripped by an experience like no other.


Logan proves its worth as one of the greatest superhero films ever made, delivering a profound narrative that transcends the boundaries of its genre. James Mangold’s direction, coupled with exceptional performances from Hugh Jackman, Patrick Stewart, and Dafne Keen, bring to life a story of pain, redemption, and the power of human connection. This bittersweet farewell to Wolverine cements it as a remarkable achievement and an essential watch for both fans and newcomers to the superhero genre.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is Logan suitable for younger audiences?

Logan’s mature and violent content make it more appropriate for mature audiences. The film delves into darker themes and includes graphic violence, which may not be suitable for younger viewers.

2. How does Logan compare to other superhero films?

Logan stands out among superhero films due to its mature storytelling, exceptional performances, and unique blend of genres. It delves deeper into the complexities of its characters, offering a more nuanced and emotionally resonant experience than many other movies in the genre.

3. Can I watch Logan as a standalone film?

While knowledge of Wolverine and the X-Men universe enriches the viewing experience, Logan can be enjoyed as a standalone film. Its compelling storytelling and character development make it accessible to both newcomers and longtime fans of the franchise.

4. What elements make Logan a standout superhero film?

Logan’s standout elements include its poignant exploration of aging superheroes, its incorporation of the Western genre, and its commitment to a more mature and gritty tone. The film’s exceptional performances and its ability to balance raw emotion with thrilling action sequences further contribute to its distinction.

5. Are there plans for further exploration of Logan’s character in the future?

While Logan serves as a fitting conclusion to Hugh Jackman’s portrayal of Wolverine, plans for future exploration of the character’s story have been announced. The upcoming Deadpool 3 is confirmed to feature Jackman reprising his role, albeit in what capacity remains to be seen. Fans eagerly await further developments to witness how Logan’s legacy unfolds.