Mr. Malcolm’s List Review Film Comedy

Movie Bunker Score:

Mr Malcolm’s List: A Breath of Fresh Air in the World of Period Dramas

A Diverse Cast and a Delightfully Witty Script

Mr Malcolm’s List, directed by Emma Holly Jones, offers a refreshing take on the traditional period drama genre. With its diverse cast and razor-sharp script, this Jane Austen-style story stands out from the crowd. Following in the footsteps of films like The Personal History of David Copperfield, Mr Malcolm’s List embraces inclusivity with actors such as Dev Patel, Freida Pinto, Ṣọpẹ Dìrísù, Zawe Ashton, and Oliver Jackson-Cohen taking on key roles. While the film may adhere to certain conventions, its vibrant energy, sharp humor, and endearing romance make it a winning formula.

At the heart of the film is Ṣọpẹ Dìrísù’s portrayal of Mr. Malcolm, a man of high societal standing known for evaluating women against a checklist of wifely requirements. When he rejects Selina Dalton, played by Freida Pinto, a playful tale of revenge is set in motion, led by the remarkable Julia Thistlewaite, portrayed by Zawe Ashton. Alongside this central romantic conflict, the film weaves in various subplots, including Julia’s own love story and the comical escapades of Lord Cassidy, played by Oliver Jackson-Cohen. Adapted from Suzanne Allain’s book of the same name, the screenplay strikes a balance between period drama and farce, offering an entertaining and light-hearted viewing experience.

The Flawed Gender Politics and Feminist Messages

While Mr. Malcolm’s List excels in its comedic moments, its handling of gender politics and feminist themes often falls short. Despite his checklist, Mr. Malcolm is not vilified; instead, he gradually learns from his mistakes, and Selina is empowered to retaliate on her own terms. However, the occasional portrayal of Mr. Malcolm as a victim feels misguided. The film ultimately lacks true villains, embracing the general happiness commonly seen in Regency-set romances. Notably, Zawe Ashton and Oliver Jackson-Cohen shine as Julia and Lord Cassidy, injecting the already hilarious script with vivacity and impeccable timing. Their chemistry, along with the sweet and believable romance between Selina and Mr. Malcolm, adds depth to the film.

The Immersive Setting and Engaging Performances

Mr Malcolm’s List captivates viewers with its stunning set designs, exquisite costumes, and picturesque English countryside backdrop. Fans of the genre will find themselves immersed in a world that effortlessly captures the essence of a classic period drama. Emma Holly Jones’s direction is skillful and inventive, bringing out the best in an impressive cast that keeps the audience entertained from start to finish. While the film’s conclusion may be predictable, it never fails to sparkle with its playful homage to beloved classics like Pride and Prejudice (2005). Mr Malcolm’s List may not revolutionize the genre, but it guarantees a thoroughly enjoyable experience.


In summary, Mr Malcolm’s List breathes new life into the world of period dramas through its diverse cast, sharp writing, and delightful humor. While it may stumble in its exploration of gender politics and feminist messages, the film compensates with its genuine charm and engaging performances. With a visually enchanting setting and a talented ensemble, this movie successfully captures the essence of a classic romance while offering a fresh perspective. If you’re a fan of the genre, be prepared for a delightful, lighthearted, and thoroughly enjoyable experience.


1. When will Mr Malcolm’s List be released?

Mr Malcolm’s List will be released in UK cinemas nationwide starting from Friday, August 26, 2022.

2. Can I watch Mr Malcolm’s List on VOD?

Yes, the film is now available to watch on Video on Demand (VOD) in the United States.

3. Who is the director of Mr Malcolm’s List?

Emma Holly Jones makes her feature film directorial debut with Mr Malcolm’s List.

4. What is the runtime of Mr Malcolm’s List?

The film has a brisk and zippy runtime of 117 minutes, ensuring an engaging and entertaining experience.

5. Does Mr Malcolm’s List bring anything new to the genre?

While the film doesn’t revolutionize the period drama genre, it offers a refreshing take with its diverse cast, witty script, and immersive setting. Viewers can expect a charming and enjoyable film that stays true to the genre’s beloved tropes.