In the dark underbelly of Scarborough, a serene New England town, “Reptile” weaves a tale of grisly murder and enigmatic suspects. Benicio del Toro shines as Tom Nichols, a seasoned detective, whose nuanced performance keeps the audience guessing. The film kicks off with the shocking discovery of Summer’s brutal murder, setting the stage for a gripping thriller that unfolds with sinister twists.
Director Grant Singer pays homage to the genre’s classics, notably drawing inspiration from Michael Mann’s “Manhunter.” The film’s atmosphere is thick with quiet, ominous music and palpable tension, adding layers of suspense to the narrative. As the investigation deepens, a web of suspects emerges, each one more intriguing than the last.
Justin Timberlake delivers a compelling portrayal of Will Grady, a man caught in a web of suspicion. Is he the cold-blooded killer, or is there more to his story? The supporting cast, including Karl Glusman and Michael Carmen Pitt, adds depth to the array of suspects, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats.
“Reptile” excels in crafting a captivating whodunit, reminiscent of classic cop dramas. Del Toro’s performance as Tom Nichols, coupled with the camaraderie among his fellow officers, creates a compelling ensemble dynamic. However, beneath the surface, the film struggles to reconcile its initial portrayal of the murder’s brutality with the eventual explanation, leaving viewers questioning the true nature of the crime.
Despite its minor inconsistencies, “Reptile” offers a satisfying blend of suspense and intrigue. While it may not redefine the genre, it successfully keeps the audience engaged with its enigmatic plot and well-executed performances. For fans of crime thrillers, “Reptile” provides an enjoyable cinematic experience, even if it occasionally loses its grip on its own premise.